MishpishDo students have the right to free speech?
March 22nd 2007 02:16
Students win lawsuit after making killer teddy bear movie
I always love a law case where students sue school. Why didn't I think of doing that? Four students were kicked out of school for making a movie about a teddy bear who tries to kill a teacher and his wife. Apparently the school didn't see the humour. The students sued the school for taking away their right to freedom of speech. And they won. More importantly however, they're allowed to go back to school.
Full article below from Associated Press:
KNIGHTSTOWN, Indiana (AP) -- Three students expelled for making a movie in which evil teddy bears attack a teacher will share $69,000 in a settlement of their civil rights lawsuit.
The board of the Charles A. Beard School Corp. voted 5-2 on Tuesday to approve the settlement of the lawsuit, which stemmed from the school's response to a movie called "The Teddy Bear Master."
The expulsions will be erased from the record and the students will be allowed to make up for missed work. Two of them still must write letters of apology to a teacher named in the movie and his wife.
In the movie, the "teddy bear master" orders stuffed animals to kill a teacher who had embarrassed him, but students battle the toy beasts, according to documents filed in court.
School officials last year expelled the four students who made the film, arguing that it was disruptive and they saw it as a threat to Knightstown Intermediate School teacher Dan Clevenger.
Two of the students sued, claiming their free-speech rights were violated. A federal judge in December ordered that school officials allow them back into class, saying that although the students should apologize for the "humiliating" and "obscene" movie, district officials had not proven that the work disrupted school.
A third student joined the lawsuit after it was filed, and the fourth student did not challenge the expulsion.
Superintendent David McGuire said the school district's insurance company will cover the cost of the $69,000 settlement that will be split among the plaintiffs.
Knightstown is about 35 miles east of Indianapolis.
Do students have the right to free speech? Should they have won the law suit?
I always love a law case where students sue school. Why didn't I think of doing that? Four students were kicked out of school for making a movie about a teddy bear who tries to kill a teacher and his wife. Apparently the school didn't see the humour. The students sued the school for taking away their right to freedom of speech. And they won. More importantly however, they're allowed to go back to school.
not as innocent as he looks
Full article below from Associated Press:
KNIGHTSTOWN, Indiana (AP) -- Three students expelled for making a movie in which evil teddy bears attack a teacher will share $69,000 in a settlement of their civil rights lawsuit.
The board of the Charles A. Beard School Corp. voted 5-2 on Tuesday to approve the settlement of the lawsuit, which stemmed from the school's response to a movie called "The Teddy Bear Master."
The expulsions will be erased from the record and the students will be allowed to make up for missed work. Two of them still must write letters of apology to a teacher named in the movie and his wife.
In the movie, the "teddy bear master" orders stuffed animals to kill a teacher who had embarrassed him, but students battle the toy beasts, according to documents filed in court.
School officials last year expelled the four students who made the film, arguing that it was disruptive and they saw it as a threat to Knightstown Intermediate School teacher Dan Clevenger.
Two of the students sued, claiming their free-speech rights were violated. A federal judge in December ordered that school officials allow them back into class, saying that although the students should apologize for the "humiliating" and "obscene" movie, district officials had not proven that the work disrupted school.
A third student joined the lawsuit after it was filed, and the fourth student did not challenge the expulsion.
Superintendent David McGuire said the school district's insurance company will cover the cost of the $69,000 settlement that will be split among the plaintiffs.
Knightstown is about 35 miles east of Indianapolis.
Do students have the right to free speech? Should they have won the law suit?
| 54 |
| Vote |
Shared on
Subscribe to this blog
Comment by Nina